A Review of Restoration Techniques and Outcomes for Rangelands Affected by Oil and Gas Production in North America

References

1. 1. Achang, M.,
   2. L. Yanyao and
   3. M. Radonjic

   . 2020. A review of past, present, and future technologies for permanent plugging and abandonment of wellbores and restoration of subsurface geologic barriers. Environmental Engineering Science 37:395–408.

   OpenUrl
2. 1. Allred, B.W.,
   2. W.K. Smith,
   3. D. Twidwell,
   4. J.H. Haggerty,
   5. S.W. Running,
   6. D.E. Naugle

   , et al. 2015. Ecosystem services lost to oil and gas in North America. Science 348:401–402.

   OpenUrlAbstract/FREE Full Text
3. 1. Akbari, S. and
   2. S.M. Taghavi

   . 2021. Fluid experiments on the dump bailing methods in the plug and abandonment of oil and gas wells. Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering 205:108920.

   OpenUrl
4. 1. Al Ramadan, M.,
   2. S. Salehi,
   3. G. Kwatia,
   4. C. Ezeakacha and
   5. C. Teodo-riu

   . 2019. Experimental investigation of well integrity: Annular gas migration in cement column. Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering 179:126–135.

   OpenUrl
5. 1. Anthony, E.J. and
   2. J. Wang

   . 2006. Pilot plant investigations of thermal remediation of tar-contaminated soil and oil-contaminated gravel. Fuel 85:443–450.

   OpenUrl
6. 1. Arnold, R.N.

   2009. Revegetation of disturbed well sites with selected cool season native and non-native grasses for stand establishment in the Intermountain region of Northwest Mexico. NM State University Agricultural Experiment Station. Research Report 768.
7. 1. Avirmed, O.,
   2. I.C. Burke,
   3. M.L. Mobley,
   4. W.K. Lauenroth and
   5. D.R. Schlaepfer

   . 2014. Natural recovery of soil organic matter in 30–90-year-old abandoned oil and gas wells in sagebrush steppe. Ecosphere 5:24.

   OpenUrl
8. 1. Avirmed, O.,
   2. W.K. Lauenroth,
   3. I.C. Burke and
   4. M.L. Mobley

   . 2015. Sagebrush steppe recovery on 30–90–year-old abandoned oil and gas wells. Ecosphere 6:115.

   OpenUrl
9. 1. Bailey, D.W.,
   2. J.C. Mosley,
   3. R.E. Estell,
   4. A.F. Cibils,
   5. M. Horney,
   6. J.R. Hendrickson

   et al. 2019. Synthesis paper: Targeted livestock grazing:Prescription for healthy rangelands. Rangeland Ecology & Management 72:865–877.

   OpenUrl
10. 1. Baughman, O.W.,
    2. A.C. Agneray,
    3. M.L. Forister,
    4. F.F. Kilkenny,
    5. E.K. Espeland,
    6. R. Fiegener

    , et al. 2019. Strong patterns of intraspecific variation and local adaptation in Great Basin plants revealed through a review of 75 years of experiments. Ecology and Evolution 9:6259–6275.

    OpenUrl
11. 1. Baynard, C.W.,
    2. K. Mjachina,
    3. R.D. Richardson,
    4. R.W. Schupp,
    5. J.D. Lambert and
    6. A.A. Chibilyev

    . 2017. Energy development in Colorado’s Pawnee National Grasslands: Mapping and measuring the disturbance footprint of renewables and non-renewables. Environmental Management 59:995–1016.

    OpenUrl
12. 1. Bernath-Plaisted, J. and
    2. N. Koper

    . 2016. Physical footprint of oil and gas infrastructure, not anthropogenic noise, reduces nesting success of some grassland songbirds. Biological Conservation 204:434–441.

    OpenUrl
13. 1. Bradshaw, A.D.

    1987. The reclamation of derelict land and the ecology of ecosystems. Pages 53–74 in W.R. Jordan, M.E. Gilpin, and J. D. Aber (eds), Restoration Ecology: A Synthetic Approach to Ecological Research. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
14. 1. Brown, J.R., and
    2. N.D. MacLeod

    . 2018. An ecosystem services filter for rangeland restoration. The Rangeland Journal 39:451–459.

    OpenUrl
15. 1. Chomphosy, W.H.,
    2. S. Varriano,
    3. L.H. Lefler,
    4. V. Nallur,
    5. M.R. McClung and
    6. M.D. Moran

    . 2021. Ecosystem services benefits from the restoration of non-producing US oil and gas lands. Nature Sustainability 4:547–554.

    OpenUrl
16. 1. Cooper, J.,
    2. L. Stamford and
    3. A. Azapagic

    . 2016. Shale gas: A review of the economic, environmental, and social sustainability. Energy Technology 4:772–792.

    OpenUrl
17. 1. Croat, S.J.,
    2. P.L. O’Brien,
    3. C.K. Gasch,
    4. F.X.M. Casey and
    5. T.M. DeSutter

    . 2020. Crop production on heavily disturbed soils following crude oil remediation. Agronomy Journal 112:130–138.

    OpenUrl
18. 1. Davies, R.J.,
    2. S. Almond,
    3. R.S. Ward,
    4. R.B. Jackson,
    5. C. Adams,
    6. F. Worrall

    , et al. 2014. Oil and gas wells and their integrity: Implications for shale and unconventional resource exploitation. Marine and Petroleum Geology 56:239–254.

    OpenUrlGeoRef
19. 1. DeLaune, R.D. and
    2. A.L. Wright

    . 2011. Projected impact of Deepwater Horizon oil spill on U.S. Gulf Coast wetlands. Soil Science Society of America Journal 75:1602–1612.

    OpenUrlCrossRef
20. 1. Desserud, P.A. and
    2. C.H. Hugenholtz

    . 2017. Restoring industrial disturbances with native hay in mixedgrass prairie in Alberta. Ecological Restoration 35:228–236.

    OpenUrlAbstract/FREE Full Text
21. 1. Desserud, P.A. and
    2. M.A. Naeth

    . 2014. Predicting grassland recovery with a state and transition model in a natural area, central Alberta, Canada. Natural Areas Journal 34:429–442.

    OpenUrl
22. 1. Dornbusch, M.J.,
    2. R.F. Limb,
    3. H.A.K. Tomlinson,
    4. A.L.M. Daigh and
    5. K. K. Sedivec

    . 2020. Evaluation of soil treatment techniques on remediated brine spill sites in semi-arid rangelands. Journal of Environmental Management 260:1–9.

    OpenUrl
23. 1. Eldridge, J.D.,
    2. E.F. Redente and
    3. M. Paschke

    . 2012. The use of seedbed modifications and wood chips to accelerate restoration of well pad sites in Western Colorado, U.S.A. Restoration Ecology 20:524–531.

    OpenUrl
24. 1. Espeland, E.K.

    2014. Choosing a reclamation seed mix to maintain rangelands during energy development in the Bakken. Rangelands 36:25–28.

    OpenUrl
25. 1. Espeland, E.K.,
    2. J. Hendrickson,
    3. D. Toledo,
    4. N.M. West and
    5. T.A. Rand

    . 2017. Soils determine early revegetation establishment with and without cover crops in northern mixed grass prairie after energy development. Ecological Restoration 35:311–319.

    OpenUrlAbstract/FREE Full Text
26. 1. Falk, A.D.,
    2. K.A. Pawelek,
    3. F.S. Smith,
    4. V. Cash and
    5. M. Schnupp

    . 2017. Evaluation of locally-adapted native seed sources and impacts of livestock grazing for restoration of historic oil pad sites in south Texas. Ecological Restoration 35:120–126.

    OpenUrlAbstract/FREE Full Text
27. 1. Fontenot, B.E.,
    2. L.R. Hunt,
    3. Z.L. Hildenbrand,
    4. D.D. Carlton,
    5. H. Oka,
    6. J.L. Walton

    , et al. 2013. An evaluation of water quality in private drinking water wells near natural gas extraction sites in the Barnett Shale formation. Environmental Science and Technology 47:10032–10040.

    OpenUrlCrossRefPubMedWeb of Science
28. 1. Gann, G.D.,
    2. T. McDonald,
    3. B. Walder,
    4. J. Aronson,
    5. C.R. Nelson,
    6. J. Jonson

    , et al. 2019. International principles and standards for the practice of ecological restoration. Second edition. Restoration Ecology 27:S1–S46.

    OpenUrl
29. 1. Gaskin, J.F.,
    2. E. Espeland,
    3. C.D. Johnson,
    4. D.L. Larson,
    5. J.M. Mangold,
    6. R.A. McGee

    , et al. 2021. Managing invasive plants on Great Plains grasslands: A discussion of current challenges. Rangeland Ecology & Management 78:235–249.

    OpenUrl
30. 1. Hardegree, S.P.,
    2. J.T. Abatzoglou,
    3. M.W. Brunson,
    4. M.J. Germino,
    5. K.C. Hegewisch,
    6. C.A. Moffet

    , et al. 2018. Weather-centric rangeland revegetation planning. Rangeland Ecology & Management 71:1–11.

    OpenUrl
31. 1. Havrilla, C.A.,
    2. S.M. Munson,
    3. E.O. Yackulic and
    4. B.J. Butterfield

    . 2021. Ontogenetic trait shifts: Seedlings display high trait variability during early stages of development. Functional Ecology 35:2409–2423.

    OpenUrl
32. 1. Hildenbrand, Z.L.,
    2. D.D. Carlton,
    3. B.E. Fontenot,
    4. J.M. Meik,
    5. J.L. Walton,
    6. J.T. Taylor

    , et al. 2015. A comprehensive analysis of groundwater quality in the Barnett Shale region. Environmental Science and Technology 49:8254–8262.

    OpenUrlCrossRef
33. 1. Ho, J.S.,
    2. J.-S. Shih,
    3. L.A. Muehlenbachs,
    4. C. Munnings and
    5. A.J. Krupnick

    . 2018. Managing environmental liability: An evaluation of bonding requirements for oil and gas wells in the United States. Environmental Science and Technology 66:180–190.

    OpenUrl
34. 1. Holechek, J.L. and
    2. M.N. Sawalhah

    . 2014. Energy and rangelands: A perspective. Rangelands 36(6):36–43.

    OpenUrl
35. 1. Howarth, R.W.

    2014. A bridge to nowhere: Methane emissions and the greenhouse gas footprint of natural gas. Energy Science & Engineering 2:47–60.

    OpenUrl
36. Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act. § 40601 (2021). https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/house-bill/3684/text.
37. 1. Jacquet, J.B.

    2014. Review of risks to communities from shale energy development. Environmental Science & Technology 48: 8321–8333.

    OpenUrl
38. 1. Kang, M.,
    2. S. Christian,
    3. M.A. Celia,
    4. D.L. Mauzerall,
    5. M. Bill,
    6. A.R. Miller

    , et al. 2016. Identification and characterization of high methane-emitting abandoned oil and gas wells. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 113:13636–13641.

    OpenUrlAbstract/FREE Full Text
39. 1. Kiran, R.,
    2. C. Teodoriu,
    3. Y. Dadmohammadi,
    4. R. Nygaard,
    5. D. Wood,
    6. M. Mokhtari and
    7. S. Salehi

    . 2017. Identification and evaluation of well integrity and causes of failure of well integrity barriers (A review). Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering 45:511–526.

    OpenUrl
40. 1. Klaustermeier, A.W.,
    2. A.L.M. Daigh,
    3. R.F. Limb and
    4. K. Sedivec

    . 2017. Crystallization inhibitors and their remediation potential on brine contaminated soils. Vadose Zone Journal 16(4):1–10.

    OpenUrl
41. 1. Koper, N.,
    2. K. Molloy,
    3. L. Leston and
    4. J. Yoo

    . 2014. Effects of livestock grazing and well construction on prairie vegetation structure surrounding shallow natural gas wells. Environmental Management 54:1131–1138.

    OpenUrl
42. 1. Lave, R. and
    2. B. Lutz

    . 2014. Hydraulic fracturing: A critical physical geography review. Geography Compass 8:739–754.

    OpenUrl
43. 1. McKone, M.J. and
    2. D.L. Hernández

    . 2021. Community-level assisted migration for climate-appropriate prairie restoration. Restoration Ecology 29:e13416.

    OpenUrl
44. 1. Meehan, M.,
    2. K. Sedivec,
    3. T. DeSutter,
    4. C. Augustin and
    5. A. Daigh

    . 2017. Environmental impacts of brine (produced water). North Dakota State University Extension Service (R1850). https://www.ag.ndsu.edu/publications/environment-natural-resources/environmental-impacts-of-brine-produced-water.
45. 1. Mitchell, A.L. and
    2. E.A. Casman

    . 2011. Economic incentives and regulatory framework for shale gas well site reclamation in Pennsylvania. Environmental Science & Technology 45:9506–9514.

    OpenUrl
46. 1. Mollard, F.P.O.,
    2. M.A. Naeth and
    3. A. Cohen-Fernandez

    . 2016. Mulch amendment facilitates early revegetation development on an abandoned field in northern mixed grass prairies of North America. Ecological Engineering 97:284–291.

    OpenUrl
47. 1. Moran, M.D.,
    2. N.T. Taylor,
    3. T.F. Mullins,
    4. S.S. Sardar and
    5. M.R. McClung

    . 2017. Land-use and ecosystem services costs of unconventional US oil and gas development. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 15:237–242.

    OpenUrl
48. 1. Nallur, V.,
    2. M.R. McClung and
    3. M.D. Moran

    . 2020. Potential for reclamation of abandoned gas wells to restore ecosystem services in the Fayetteville Shale of Arkansas. Environmental Management 66:180–190.

    OpenUrl
49. 1. Nasen, L.C.,
    2. B.F. Noble and
    3. J.F. Johnstone

    . 2011. Environmental effects of oil and gas lease sites in a grassland ecosystem. Journal of Environmental Management 92:195–204.

    OpenUrlPubMed
50. 1. Nordvik, A.B.,
    2. J.L. Simmons,
    3. K.R. Bitting,
    4. A. Lewis and
    5. T. Strom-Kristiansen

    . 1996. Oil and water separation in marine oil spill clean-up operations. Spill Science and Technology Bulletin 3:107–122.

    OpenUrl
51. 1. Norton, J. and
    2. C. Strom

    . 2013. Reclamation considerations for oil and gas lease contracts on private lands. WY Reclamation and Restoration Center Bulletin (publication #B-1242, 8 pp). https://www.wyoextension.org/publications/Search_Details.php?pubid=1826&pub=B-1242.
52. 1. Odokuma, L.O and
    2. A.A. Dickson

    . 2003. Bioremediation of crude oil polluted tropical rainforest soil. Global Journal of Environmental Sciences 2:29–40.

    OpenUrl
53. 1. Ott, J.P.,
    2. B.B. Hanberry,
    3. M. Khalil,
    4. M.W. Paschke,
    5. M. Post van der Burg and
    6. A.J. Prenni

    . 2021. Energy development and production in the Great Plains: Implications and mitigation opportunities. Rangeland Ecology & Management 78:257–272.

    OpenUrl
54. 1. Pawelek, K.A.,
    2. F.S. Smith,
    3. A.D. Falk,
    4. M.K. Clayton,
    5. K.W. Haby and
    6. D.W. Rankin

    . 2015. Comparing three common seeding techniques for pipeline vegetation restoration: A case study in south Texas. Rangelands 37:99–105.

    OpenUrl
55. 1. Pierre, J.P.,
    2. J.R. Andrews,
    3. M.H. Young,
    4. A.Y. Sun and
    5. B.D. Wolaver

    . 2020. Projected landscape impacts from oil and gas development scenarios in the Permian Basin, USA. Environmental Management 66:348–363.

    OpenUrl
56. 1. Pollin, R. and
    2. S. Chakraborty

    . 2020. Job creation estimates through proposed economic stimulus measures: Modeling proposals by various U.S. civil society groups. Political Economy Research Institute Report. https://www.peri.umass.edu/images/Pollin—Sierra_Club_Job_Creation—9-9-20--FINAL.pdf.
57. 1. Raimi D,
    2. A.J. Krupnick,
    3. J.-S. Shih and
    4. A. Thompson

    . 2021a. Decommissioning orphaned and abandoned oil and gas wells: New estimates and cost drivers. Environmental Science and Technology 55:10224–10230.

    OpenUrl
58. 1. Raimi, D.,
    2. A. Barone,
    3. S. Carley,
    4. D. Foster,
    5. E. Grubert,
    6. J. Haggerty

    et al. 2021b. Policy options to enable an equitable energy transition. Resources for the Future Report 21–09. https://www.rff.org/publications/reports/policy-options-to-enable-an-equitable-energy-transition/.
59. 1. Robson, D.B.,
    2. J.D. Knight,
    3. R.E. Farrell and
    4. J.J. Germida

    . 2004. Natural revegetation of hydrocarbon-contaminated soil in semi-arid grasslands. Canadian Journal of Botany 82: 22–30.

    OpenUrl
60. 1. Rottler, C.M.,
    2. I.C. Burke,
    3. K.A. Palmquist,
    4. J.B. Bradford and
    5. W.K. Lauenroth

    . 2017. Current reclamation practices after oil and gas development do not speed up succession or plant community recovery in big sagebrush ecosystems in Wyoming. Restoration Ecology 26:114–123.

    OpenUrl
61. 1. Sam, K. and
    2. N. Zabbey

    . 2018. Contaminated land and wetland remediation in Nigeria: Opportunities for sustainable livelihood creation. Science of the Total Environment 639:1560–1573.

    OpenUrl
62. 1. Simmers, S.M. and
    2. S.M. Galatowitsch

    . 2010. Factors affecting revegetation of oil field access roads in semiarid grassland. Restoration Ecology 18:27–39.

    OpenUrl
63. 1. Smith, F.S.,
    2. A.D. Falk,
    3. K.A. Pawelek and
    4. D.B. Wester

    . 2020a. Native habitat restoration in the Eagle Ford Shale of Texas. Wildlife Management Bulletin of the Caesar Kleberg Wildlife Research Institute, Texas A&M University-Kingsville (Management Bulletin No. 9). https://www.ckwri.tamuk.edu/news-events/management-bulletin-no-9-native-habitat-restoration-eagle-ford-shale-texas-0.
64. 1. Smith, F.S.,
    2. J.P. Pierre,
    3. M.H. Young and
    4. D.A. Devitt

    . 2020b. Estimation of future native grass seed demand for restoring oil and gas-energy sprawl in west Texas, USA. Ecological Restoration 38:237–245.

    OpenUrlAbstract/FREE Full Text
65. Society for Range Management. 1998. A glossary of terms used in range management (last accessed 4 January 2022). https://rangelandsgateway.org/glossary.
66. 1. Sylvain, Z.A.,
    2. E.K. Espeland,
    3. T.A. Rand,
    4. N.M. West and
    5. D.H. Branson

    . 2019. Oilfield reclamation recovers productivity but not composition of arthropod herbivores and predators. Environmental Entomology 48:299–308.

    OpenUrl
67. 1. Townsend-Small, A.,
    2. T.W. Ferrara,
    3. D.R. Lyon,
    4. A.E. Fries and
    5. B.K. Lamb

    . 2016. Emissions of coalbed and natural gas methane from abandoned oil and gas wells in the United States. Geophysical Research Letters 43:2283–2290.

    OpenUrlCrossRef
68. 1. Trainor, A.M.,
    2. R.I. McDonald and
    3. J. Fargione

    . 2016. Energy sprawl is the largest driver of land use change in United States. PLOS ONE 11:1–16.

    OpenUrlCrossRefPubMed
69. U.S. Energy Information Administration. 2020. U.S. oil and natural gas wells by production rate (last accessed 30 June 2021). https://www.eia.gov/petroleum/wells/.
70. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA). 1994. How to evaluate alternative cleanup technologies for underground storage tank sites (last accessed 7 September 2021). https://www.epa.gov/sites/production/files/2014-03/documents/tum_ch5.pdf.
71. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA). 2018. Inventory of U.S. greenhouse gas emissions and sinks 1990–2016: Abandoned oil and gas wells (last accessed 12 August 2022). https://www.epa.gov/sites/production/files/2018-04/documents/ghgemissions_abandoned_wells.pdf.
72. 1. Varona-Torres, E.,
    2. D.D. Carlton,
    3. B. Payne,
    4. Z.L. Hildenbrand and
    5. K.A. Schug

    . 2017. The characterization of BTEX in variable soil compositions near unconventional oil and gas development. Advances in Chemical Pollution, Environmental Management and Protection 1:321–351.

    OpenUrl
73. 1. Viall, E.M.,
    2. L.F. Gentry,
    3. D.G. Hopkins,
    4. A.C. Ganguli and
    5. P. Stahl

    . 2011. Legacy effects of oil road reclamation on soil biology and plant community composition. Restoration Ecology 22:625–632.

    OpenUrl
74. 1. Walton, W.D. and
    2. N.H. Jason

    . 1998. In Situ Burning of Oil Spills Workshop Proceedings. 115. https://www.bsee.gov/sites/bsee.gov/files/osrr-oil-spill-response-research/102dh.pdf.
75. 1. Wester, D.B.,
    2. J.B. Hoffman,
    3. S. Rideout-Hanzak,
    4. D.E. Ruppert,
    5. V. Acosta-Martinéz,
    6. F.S. Smith

    , et al. 2019. Restoration of mixed soils along pipelines in the western Rio Grande Plains, Texas, USA. Journal of Arid Environments 161:25–34.

    OpenUrl
76. 1. Wolaver, B.D.,
    2. J.P. Pierre,
    3. B.J. Labay,
    4. T.J. LaDuc,
    5. C.M. Duran,
    6. W.A. Ryberg and
    7. T.J. Hibbitts

    . 2018. An approach for evaluating changes in land-use from energy sprawl and other anthropogenic activities with implications for biotic resource management. Environmental Earth Sciences 77:171.

    OpenUrl
77. 1. Zirogiannis, N.,
    2. J. Alcorn,
    3. J. Rupp,
    4. S. Carley and
    5. J.D. Graham

    . State regulation of unconventional gas development in the U.S.: An empirical evaluation. Energy Research & Social Science 11:142–154.